What if the money you’re about to hand the IRS could be working for you instead? In this episode of Thrive in Retirement, David Bezar, senior managing partner at Thrive Financial Services, sits down with Jason Pueschel of Alternative Wealth Management, a firm that consults with advisory and accounting firms on tax mitigation, to talk through tax planning strategies for retirees and pre-retirees. They cover the difference between tax preparation and tax planning, how Reg D private placements pass deductions through to investors, the oil and gas deduction that has been in the tax code for more than 80 years, and how a discounted real estate valuation inside a self-directed IRA can shrink the tax bill on a Roth conversion. Jason also explains the due diligence behind these strategies, the risks and trade-offs, and who qualifies to invest.
Key Takeaways
- Tax preparation records what already happened. Tax planning looks for deductions, credits, and deferrals during the year, before you file.
- Reg D private placements are usually structured as partnerships, so deductions can pass through to your personal tax return.
- Some real estate and oil and gas programs held in a self-directed IRA receive a discounted interim valuation, which may let you convert to a Roth and pay tax on the lower value.
- The earlier you start, the more years you have to layer these strategies with multi-year Roth conversions.
Tax Planning for Retirees: Why Tax Preparation Isn’t Enough
According to David, most retirees get tax preparation but not tax planning. Preparation is record-keeping: it tallies what already happened and tells you what you owe or what you’ll get back. Planning happens during the year, when there’s still time to create deductions, credits, and deferrals that lower the bill. Jason adds that the tax code changes constantly, from the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act to last year’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act, and each change can open or close planning opportunities, such as bonus depreciation and qualified opportunity zone funds. For a primer on how withdrawals, pensions, and Social Security are taxed, see how your retirement income actually gets taxed, and for the legal side of these strategies, read tax planning for the pre-retiree and retiree: navigating legality and legitimacy.
Related episode: How to defuse the tax bomb in your IRA
The Oil and Gas Intangible Drilling Cost Deduction
Outside an IRA, oil and gas programs can offer the intangible drilling cost (IDC) deduction, which has been in the tax code for more than 80 years. As a general partner, you’re allocated the startup costs of drilling, such as clearing the ground and preparing the site, up to the point the pipe goes in the ground. Jason says these deductions have ranged from about 70% to 90% of the amount invested, so a $100,000 investment might produce a $75,000 deduction against gross income. Many programs joint venture with large operators across a portfolio of wells, and the goal is potential cash flow for 10 to 15 years. As David points out, this can be especially useful while you’re still working and three to five years from retirement.
Risks and Trade-Offs to Understand
Jason is clear that these are alternative investments with real risks, best used as one part of a diversified plan:
- Illiquidity: you generally can’t sell or withdraw for several years. Jason argues this can also keep investors from panic selling, but it means the money must be money you won’t need soon.
- Real estate market risk: rising interest rates and overdevelopment led to a 15% to 25% real estate pullback in 2022, depending on the market.
- Oil and gas price and quantity risk: sponsors spread investments across 150 or more wells and use hedges called collars that typically lock in a $60 to $80 price band.
- Sponsor and IRS scrutiny risk: which is why third-party due diligence matters.
When to Start Using Tax Planning Strategies for Retirees
These private placements are generally limited to accredited investors, and the older the client, the more scrutiny the suitability review gets. Timing matters too. Starting in your early to mid-60s may give you about a 10-year runway to pair annual Roth conversions with deductions, keeping you in a reasonable tax bracket and helping you avoid surprises like an IRMAA surcharge on your Medicare premiums. Starting in your 70s still helps; conversions may simply happen more slowly, and a smaller IRA left to beneficiaries means less for them to withdraw under the 10-year rule. Taxes are the T in Thrive’s ROUTE framework, so if you want to see how your plan scores, try our retirement planning checklist. And if your current advisor has never raised these topics, here’s how to re-interview your financial advisor before retirement.
Full Episode Transcript
This transcript has been lightly edited for readability.
[0:00] Jason: So look at it like this: instead of writing that check to the IRS, you’re diverting that money over to investments and a portfolio of oil and gas that’s going to create potential cash flow for you for 10 to 15 years. There’s actually a benefit of not having that immediate satisfaction and liquidity. It protects you from the gyrations and the volatility of the market.
Why Tax Planning Is Thrive’s “Secret Sauce”
[0:28] David: Hey folks, welcome in to another edition of our podcast, Thrive in Retirement. We’ve got a great show lined up for you today, and I’m very excited about it. What we’re going to talk about today is some of the unique things we do as a firm here at Thrive Financial. One of the goals of our firm is to help retirees plan for a very tax-efficient retirement. And to do that, you can’t just use the conventional wisdom and tools that are out there. You have to look at the things that sit in most people’s periphery, things they don’t really understand or know how they work.
[1:08] David: Bringing these types of tools to the retirement community, where we’re able to create deductions and deferrals and all sorts of ways to become really tax efficient, is what I’d call our secret sauce. And to make that secret sauce a reality and successful for the firm, we partnered with a great firm and a great person, Jason Pueschel. Jason is our guest on the show today, and I’m very excited to have you with us, Jason. Why don’t you take a minute to introduce yourself and tell us a little bit about your firm?
Meet Jason Pueschel
[1:43] Jason: Yeah, thanks, David. I appreciate you having me on, and I’ve really enjoyed working with your firm over the years. As you mentioned, we’re a unique entity. We act as outsourced consultants to registered investment advisors, other advisory firms, and accounting professionals, and our niche focus is purely tax mitigation. We are financial advisors, and I’m a registered representative myself, but we don’t do traditional asset management and we don’t do financial planning. We stay right in our lane, which is tax mitigation strategies.
[2:17] Jason: As for my background, I’ve been in the financial services industry for quite a long time. I got licensed back in ’92, and for over 25 years I worked with a lot of the different product sponsors in the industry, helping them create programs they could deliver to their clients and structure products for the marketplace. So I learned that side of the business, the construction of different programs. That gives me a great viewpoint now that I’m on this side, where we’re facilitating investments for retail clients and analyzing a lot of the programs these sponsors bring to market. It’s a unique trait we have as a firm.
Why Due Diligence Matters in Tax Strategies
[3:05] David: Yeah, and I think that’s what really attracted us a number of years ago to get connected and start to understand this aspect of tax planning. The thing I appreciate most is that you’re always operating in a fiduciary capacity, not necessarily directly for the consumer, although you do that too, but for firms like mine in that consulting position. You put in a very heavy lift to give us assurance that the tax strategies you introduce to us have been well vetted, with the due diligence reviewed to the nth degree. That’s a unique element, because there’s a lot of information out there today, and a lot of people pushing things that aren’t just on the fringe. They may have already gone over the fringe, and that can get a retiree into some trouble. So the fact that you’re part of the industry and you’ve got that fiduciary responsibility is a big deal.
[4:13] Jason: Yeah, for sure. You touched on one point we pride ourselves on, which is diligence. The type of structure we typically work with is Reg D private placements. I’m not going to get too technical, but what that means is these aren’t registered securities like a typical stock on an exchange, with all the regulatory oversight and scrutiny that comes with a registered security. What they do is create entities and structures for private participation. As an individual, you’re limited in the amount of deductions you can create yourself. So most of the programs we work with use partnership-type structures, where you come in as a partner and receive pass-through deductions you can apply to your personal tax situation.
[5:04] Jason: But the private placements themselves come in a lot of different forms, and there are a lot of different sponsors. So an extraordinary amount of diligence goes into analyzing not just what the tax benefit is, because at face value the tax benefit could look great. We’re digging into who’s offering the tax benefit, what their background is, what their history is, and doing all that type of analysis. So by the time it makes it to a conversation between you and me, David, and ultimately one of your clients, it’s gone through some very rigorous diligence.
Tax Preparation vs. Tax Planning
[5:42] David: Yeah, and that’s so highly appreciated, because it gives us the confidence to bring it to the marketplace. I think this is a great point to jump into the conversation. I’m on the front line. My whole financial advisory team and I meet with pre-retirees and retirees every week, and a lot of the reason people come to us is that they’re intrigued to learn more about the tax planning strategies Thrive has to offer. It’s not that we created these or that we’re unique in using them, but it’s an area of practice we decided to champion because we think it can have such a dramatic impact on what happens for a retiree.
[6:26] David: Quite often, based on how we structure everything, we can get retirees who never anticipated it to low single-digit or maybe low double-digit effective tax rates. When you start to show them, there’s obviously the highest degree of skepticism on their part, because no one has ever shown them this before. But coming to a firm like yours, where you bring that due diligence, and there are legal opinions, CPA letters, and tax court case law if necessary, really starts to get them over the hump from skepticism to utilization.
[7:06] David: And I think that’s really important, because here’s what we stress: there’s a major difference between tax preparation and tax planning. Tax preparation is what a lot of people do. It’s making a record of what already happened and figuring out how much in taxes you owe or how much of a refund you’ll get. There’s really no proactive approach to it. Tax planning, on the other hand, is where you figure out things you can do during a given year so that when it comes time to file, you have deductions, credits, and deferral mechanisms that reduce your overall tax burden. These are the things we talk to our clients about every week.
[7:57] David: Here’s the deal, though, and this is where we need your help, Jason. I consider a lot of these strategies Wall Street strategies that we want to bring to Main Street people. Because of what they can do, I never want this to sound like the overly sophisticated, complex foreign language of high finance that makes mainstream people say, “I don’t know, that sounds a little too crazy for me.” So let’s start by talking about what’s happening in the tax code that allows this. These things have been available for a long time, but the tax code is constantly changing, and that’s why it’s important to work with a firm that stays on top of it. Can you speak to that a little bit?
How Tax Law Changes Create Planning Opportunities
[8:55] Jason: Absolutely. Just to echo your earlier comments, the biggest regret I hear from people is not learning some of these strategies earlier in their planning days. You’re a retirement planning specialist firm, and I’m sure a lot of the folks you meet are later in their years. Having these incremental planning tools, which can really move the needle over the long term, facilitates a different type of outcome for a lot of folks.
[9:27] Jason: But that involves keeping up with the tax code year in and year out. It’s constantly evolving and changing, like the One Big Beautiful Bill Act last year, and the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act before that. To name a few things in the One Big Beautiful Bill that changed some of our current planning, we had bonus depreciation. I’ll try not to get too technical here today, David, but bonus depreciation is an incredible opportunity for those who acquire equipment and other items that are deductible all in the single year you acquire them. Some of the partnership strategies we work with involve bonus depreciation, where you can make an investment, lever it up, and take a big deduction for those items. That’s one example. Another is qualified opportunity zone funds, which maybe we’ll elaborate on a little more.
[10:31] Jason: Unless you’re staying on top of the tax code, you’re going to miss opportunities. We love the accounting professionals we partner with, and most of them are elevated, meaning they don’t just file taxes. I know your firm is uncovering a lot of clients who have worked for years with tax professionals where all that happened was, “April 15th is here, I plugged in all your numbers, and here’s what you need to write a check for.” That’s just not effective at all. If you plug in these tax code changes incrementally along the way each year, the outcome can be significant.
How Reg D Programs Are Structured and Vetted
[11:24] David: Yeah, absolutely. Let’s take a step back, because what I really want the audience to get comfortable with is the process. Maybe share a couple of minutes on what your firm does. You mentioned these are Regulation D-type products, limited partnerships. What type of investor qualifies for them, and what due diligence do you do on the vendor and the strategy to get comfortable enough to introduce them to prospective clients?
[12:01] Jason: Absolutely. There are a lot of moving parts there. When we’re analyzing programs, at the first level we’re looking at the current tax laws. Some have been in place for a very long time, like oil and gas tax strategies, where you can take a deduction for what’s called an intangible drilling cost. All that means is the startup costs for a portfolio of oil wells, and that’s been in place for over 80 years. More recently, things like qualified opportunity zone funds pop up, and you need to stay on top of new things you can plug into a client’s tax situation.
[12:38] Jason: The general structure, as I mentioned, comes in the form of a general partnership, a limited partnership, or a limited liability company. These aren’t equities or fixed income instruments, and there’s a reason for that. Being a partner puts you in a position to have pass-through expenses and deductions that apply to your personal tax return. You really can’t achieve that unless you’re an actual partner in a program. There are some other restrictions. In some, you need to become what’s called a material participant and actually do some work to be able to apply those deductions. But in most, you’re able to invest as a general partner or through a different type of structure, and it just passes through to your personal taxes.
[13:38] Jason: When we’re vetting sponsors, and we get approached by a lot of them, I would say we ultimately end up working with maybe one in five, if that, because everybody’s trying to capitalize on the promise of tax mitigation. I know you’ve run into it. There are more people out there today than I’ve ever seen trying to pitch these different strategies. To us, it’s a process of elimination on a risk level, and risk comes in a lot of different forms when it comes to tax mitigation. There’s IRS scrutiny risk, there’s program total return risk, and there’s sponsor risk: can you trust these folks, and who are the people offering these programs?
[14:24] Jason: So these are vetted individually, starting with the sponsor. Almost always there’s what’s called a third-party review, where an outside legal firm does a very extensive background check on the principals of the sponsor. They’re also vetting the performance of previous programs the sponsor may have done. So at the end of the day, we know almost everything about their background. They might be a new sponsor in the space, or new to working with us, but we know where they’ve come from.
[15:05] Jason: Then it comes down to their current proposition, the business model they put forth. For us, it typically involves some aspect of tax mitigation, but that’s rarely the deciding factor for us to move forward. It’s really about total return. The tax mitigation is usually what pushes it over the top, but the other aspects of the program are the meat of what you’re investing in. Maybe it’s real estate, maybe it’s oil and gas, but it has to make sense from a total return perspective. The tax deduction alone usually isn’t enough.
[15:50] David: That’s great information, and that’s what brings me a lot of confidence personally. As you know, Jason, you and I and Brett have gone back and forth on a number of quote-unquote opportunities. I know there’s one in front of you right now where, on the initial review, it was, “I’m not really sure.” But as the third-party review and historical data come in, that process sometimes shows that something is actually very workable.
Discounted Valuations and Tax-Efficient Roth Conversions
[16:19] David: Let’s spend a couple of minutes on actual application. Where do these types of strategies and programs fit into somebody’s retirement plan?
[16:34] Jason: Absolutely. Just to comment on that last program, I’m not going to name it, but I want to share that we’ve been doing diligence on that offering for over a year, and we haven’t signed them yet. We’ve gone back and forth: we like it, we had an issue, we needed them to prove it out, and we had more conversations with them. I think we’re probably two weeks away from signing and finally feeling comfortable. That’s the level of scrutiny we apply before bringing this into client portfolios.
[17:04] Jason: I know a lot of what you do at Thrive, David, involves retirement planning, and that’s a significant portion of what we do as well. Some of our work revolves around different ways to facilitate tax-efficient Roth conversions. I’ll use that as one example. One of our techniques is a direct transfer from a current IRA to a self-directed IRA. For those who don’t know, a self-directed IRA is nothing complicated. It just allows you to buy what are termed alternative investments, like real estate and oil and gas, as opposed to traditional investments.
[17:58] Jason: Some of the programs we work with have an independent appraisal done. From an accounting perspective, they follow some pretty strict guidelines that allow them to reprice the current value. It doesn’t affect the long-term proposition, but the current value can be marked down based on things like future construction costs and financing charges for a real estate project. If they tried to market a partially completed real estate project, they wouldn’t get a good price. People want a completed, leased-up building, and that’s what institutions are looking to buy: cash flow. So they purposefully get a valuation that’s discounted from the current amount. Typically, we’ve seen a 40% to 60% discount on the valuation.
[18:57] Jason: That facilitates a tax-efficient conversion, because as soon as we see the discount occur in the IRA, we shift it over to the Roth IRA, and the client only pays tax on the discounted amount. Let’s say they invested $100,000. The money moves from their current IRA to the self-directed IRA, and nothing is taxable there because it’s IRA to IRA. A revaluation occurs, and let’s say they mark it down from $100,000 to $60,000. This is usually when clients say, “Remind me why it’s a good thing you just knocked $40,000 off my value.” It’s on paper, folks. It’s not something that’s going to affect you long term, but it facilitates the conversion. Instead of converting $100,000, you’re converting $60,000.
[19:48] David: And you just saved paying tax on $40,000. That’s a big deal.
[19:49] Jason: The endgame is when they sell the real estate, three to five years out once the project is completed. It usually takes two and a half years to build and another six to eight months to stabilize. Then they sell it to an institution as quickly as feasible, and hopefully you get maybe a 10% return per year. There are no guarantees there, but that’s realistic. Four years later, you get $140,000 back in your Roth, which, by the way, is tax-free because it’s in the Roth, and you started by saving tax on $40,000 at conversion. Those are incremental things you can implement that move the dial each and every year.
[20:27] David: Absolutely awesome, and it’s something we talk about every single day. It’s surprising how often people say, “How come I’ve never heard about this before?” Our answer is that typical financial advisors only talk to their clients about what they get paid for, which is investment management. And because they tend to work for the bigger-name companies, these alternative strategies don’t really sit in their inventory. But at boutique, more specialized firms like yours and ours, we’re trying to get the message out to the retirement community. You could make a reasonable investment in a real estate project, and because you’re a partner in it, you’re subject to different tax rules. When that fair market appraisal comes in before the project is completed, you get somewhere between a 40% and 60% discount on the value. As you said, it’s on paper, and that’s an opportune time to do the Roth conversion, knowing you’re going to have profits in the future that are completely tax-free.
[21:44] Jason: It’s no different, really. If your mutual fund went down 30%, you’d probably say, “Hey, now’s a good time to shift it to the Roth.” The only difference, David, is that we know when the valuation is going to shift, so we can plan for it.
Oil and Gas Programs and the Intangible Drilling Cost Deduction
[21:57] David: That’s exactly right. It’s a very predictable situation. I love that example. Jason, if you don’t mind, let’s do the same type of review using oil and gas, because I know you’ve created an amazing pro forma calculator that shows the benefit of all this. Let’s talk about what kind of deduction you get on the front end of an oil and gas partnership, and maybe the same discounting mechanism, or the two combined.
[22:30] Jason: Sure. Let’s start inside the IRA, because there’s a difference between buying the strategy inside the IRA and outside it. Inside the IRA, it’s very similar to the way I described the real estate, but the discount is usually a little larger. Typically, we’ve seen anywhere from a 50% to 70% discount. But again, it can’t just be about the tax mitigation for any of these programs. There’s a cash flow component.
[23:03] Jason: With oil and gas, what you’re investing in are oil wells or natural gas wells. Most of these companies typically partner with some of the largest oil companies in the world. We’ve seen strategies partner with groups like Occidental Petroleum, Chevron, Devon Energy, and Exxon. These big-name operators look to joint venture because they have more wells they could drill and want more diversification. So you’re coming in as a joint venture partner with some of the largest oil companies, and ultimately you’re creating passive income streams. That’s the other aspect of what we do. We target a deduction, but we’re also helping people diversify their income and create different buckets and pools of cash flow.
[23:54] Jason: If you’re not doing it inside the IRA, there’s what’s called the intangible drilling cost deduction. This is hugely popular. We have clients who use it year in and year out to help reduce their current income tax liability. You come in as a general partner, and as a general partner you’re allocated these intangible drilling costs: clearing the ground, getting staff ready, everything up to the point where they put the pipe in the ground. You can deduct those as a general partner, and the deductions are pretty significant, David. From what we’ve seen and worked with, they range anywhere from 70% of your initial amount all the way up to 90%.
[24:41] Jason: So if you made an investment of, let’s say, $100,000, a typical program could provide a $75,000 deduction that comes off your gross income. It helps you plan each year to reduce your gross income. And a lot of people, myself included, and I know you as well, would rather take what would have gone to the IRS and use it to fund a passive income stream. So look at it like this: instead of writing that check to the IRS, you’re diverting that money over to investments and a portfolio of oil and gas that’s going to create potential cash flow for you for 10 to 15 years.
The Risks and Trade-Offs
[25:23] David: Yeah, absolutely. Awesome. And that deduction can really be applied while you’re still working and your retirement might be three to five years away. You want to bring that gross income down, and this is something that could help. You get that big deduction on the front end, it reduces your overall income, you pay less in taxes, and you diversify as well. So we’ve talked about some of the benefits of these types of investments. What are the trade-offs? What should people be thinking about from a risk perspective?
[26:01] Jason: Absolutely, there are risks. We balance risk and return. I would say we’re somewhat of a conservative firm, and we look to mitigate risk as much as possible. A lot of mitigating risk comes in the form of diversification, and that’s not just our strategies. It’s partnering with you, David, where you’re the quarterback of a client’s financial universe, balancing what they have in stocks and bonds and looking at these investments as part of that holistic diversification picture. Because at the end of the day, it is an investment, an alternative investment. Typically, we like to see a 10% to 20% allocation in the alternative investment sleeve, and no more than a 5% weighting in any single asset.
[26:50] Jason: Looking at the risks in real estate, you’ve got general market risk from the economy pulling back. We saw some of those risks play out earlier this decade, when interest rates spiked and developers couldn’t afford to continue a lot of projects. We had a pretty good-sized correction in real estate back in 2022, I would say a 15% to 25% pullback depending on the market. There was some overdevelopment at that point, which put pressure on rents because newer properties were hitting the market. Older properties had to keep up and reduce rents to keep their tenants from jumping to the shiny new place down the street, and that put further pressure on prices.
[27:37] Jason: That’s all good news for us today, though, because that excess supply has burned off. From 2022 to today, in 2026, there’s been underdevelopment because of high interest rates. In fact, we’re at about 2014 levels of development, and that’s expected to continue for the next few years. If we’re at equilibrium now with the supply burned off, in three to five years we should be in pretty good shape, with demand actually outpacing supply. But those are some of the risk factors with real estate: economic risk.
[28:22] Jason: With oil and gas, in my opinion, you’ve got two risks: price and quantity. Those are the biggest risks, and there are ways sponsors mitigate them. You’ll hear me talk about diversification quite a bit, and that’s how they mitigate quantity risk. The portfolios we invest in typically have north of 150 wells. You’re not sitting around with 10 wells saying, “Come on, baby, cash flow, let’s go.” It’s very diversified.
[28:51] Jason: When it comes to price, they use hedging strategies. Everybody’s very sensitive to the price of oil lately. We’ve spiked up to $100 a barrel because of geopolitical issues, and when Trump first got into office, it actually fell below $60, so it was the opposite issue. As an investor, you don’t want to see swings in either direction. It sounds counterintuitive that you wouldn’t want $100 oil, but $100 oil puts pressure on demand. And as a sponsor and investor, you’re usually not collecting $100 oil anyway, which ties in with mitigating risk.
[29:37] Jason: They use option strategies. Again, I’m trying not to get too technical today, but the option strategies they use are called collars. A collar locks in a band of prices you’re going to collect for your oil, typically $60 to $80. If the price is below $60, say $50, the other party agrees to pay you $60 for your oil. On the flip side, if it’s $100, you agree to sell your oil to them for $80. So you’re locking in a band of predictability. Those hedging strategies help safeguard against price swings, and sponsors have been doing them for years and are total experts at it.
How These Strategies Fit Into a Long-Term Retirement Plan
[30:22] David: Absolutely. Well, this has been great information. Just like with our seminars and webinars, I’m sure this creates a high degree of intrigue in the retirement community, because the biggest complaint we hear is, “I’m 70 years old and three or four years away from my required minimum distributions. I don’t really need that money. I know it’s going to bump me into the next tax bracket. I know it’s going to create a Medicare surcharge. I’ve talked to my financial advisor and my accountant, and there’s really nothing I can do.” So how can all of this be applied to them? When we’re thinking about long-term retirement planning, how do you see all of this fitting in, Jason? What would be a good idea for our listening audience?
[31:20] Jason: It’s really about layering these strategies in, David. Unfortunately, you and I are in damage-control mode a lot of the time, too. We see a lot of clients who come to us and say, “I did this, I did that, can you help?” Yes, we can help, but we’re much more effective being proactive than reactive. The longer the time horizon we have to plan and incorporate these strategies, the more effective we are.
[31:52] Jason: It also comes back to diversification. Maybe some real estate and oil and gas combined to create that alternative investment sleeve. Maybe instead of owning Exxon and Chevron as equities, you do direct participation so you can take advantage of these tax aspects. It’s really about layering these in over time so they’re very effective.
[32:14] Jason: I did want to comment on the other aspect of risk, which is illiquidity. People need to be prepared that these aren’t like equities you can trade in and out of. You’re sacrificing your ability to get immediate liquidity for the benefit. There’s actually a benefit of not having that immediate satisfaction and liquidity. It protects you from the gyrations and volatility of the market, and from other people panicking and pulling money out at the wrong time. If that happens in the stock market, you know what happens to your portfolio: you have a drastic drop. Illiquidity can actually be a benefit. It protects you from people pulling assets out at the wrong time, and you’re leveraging the track record, strength, and professionalism of the sponsor to be a steward of the capital.
Pairing Tax Strategies With Multi-Year Roth Conversions
[33:12] David: Yeah, and that’s why we couple these types of strategies with a multi-year Roth conversion strategy. It’s not an instant fix. The longer the runway, the better. If you start considering these strategies in your early to mid-60s, it may give you a 10-year horizon to do big enough Roth conversions each year, coupled with a tax mitigation strategy like the ones you’ve talked about today. That means you wouldn’t have to pay extra tax on the conversion income, because we’re using a strategy that brings you back down to a reasonable tax bracket.
[34:03] David: If you’re in your 70s, that doesn’t disqualify you. It just may not happen as quickly. We may not convert 100% of the IRA, but that’s not a terrible thing either if you’re going to leave an IRA to a beneficiary. The longer we do the conversions and reduce the balance of the IRA, the better it is for the beneficiary, because they’ll inherit a smaller IRA that they’d ultimately have to pull all the money out of within 10 years. I think our two companies combined really do bring an amazing service.
Who Qualifies for These Investments?
[34:51] David: Let’s say somebody is really interested and says, “Okay, how do I do this?” Are there any barriers to entry?
[35:01] Jason: There is a firm requirement that you need to be what’s called an accredited investor. An accredited investor is someone with $1 million of net worth excluding their home, or income of $200,000 a year for two years as a single filer, or $300,000 a year as joint filers. Those are guidelines and requirements the regulators have put in place to protect folks who might not be as sophisticated, or have the financial wherewithal, to invest in illiquid products like these.
[35:40] Jason: As for age and suitability, which you were addressing, the older the client, the more scrutiny we put on it. But as you mentioned, some folks’ ultimate goal is estate planning with some of these retirement assets: not having to take required minimum distributions, and being able to hand a bucket of money to their beneficiaries that’s already tax-free. There are some really compelling aspects to that. So we’re working with people who are older, and with people who are younger who could perhaps be more aggressive in their tax planning.
[36:23] Jason: It all comes down to tax brackets. I know Thrive is very conscious of keeping people in a certain tax bracket, so you’re not doing things by accident, where it’s, “Oh, I triggered IRMAA,” or “I pushed you into a different tax bracket.” It’s about being purposeful and setting up a strategy to do things over a period of time.
The IRS as Your “Silent Partner”
[36:48] Jason: David, I’m sure you’ve seen, like I have, a number of multimillionaires with a lot of money in their retirement accounts. They get to the point where they start distributing, and they forget about what I call the silent partner. That silent partner rides shotgun for 30 years. They love it when the stock market’s up, they’re cheering you on, and they’re quietly watching that account value grow. They don’t raise their head until you start distributing. Then that silent partner, also known as the IRS, pops up and says, “All right, let’s start withdrawals,” and they take 30% to 40%. That isn’t something clients plan for, and it’s unfortunate, because if you start early enough and build up those Roth IRA accounts, the exponential tax-free growth is tremendous.
[37:44] David: Yeah, great advice. That’s exactly it. When folks finally become aware that the IRS is their silent partner, that’s when panic strikes, and they realize they didn’t own everything in their investment portfolio. That’s why these strategies, combined with Roth conversions and the other things we do together, are really worth researching. I think today’s conversation has brought to light that there’s a major difference between tax preparation and advanced tax planning. And we’ve even taken it a step further: we can do tax planning not just with plain-vanilla Roth conversions, but by coupling them with these tax mitigation strategies.
Jason’s Advice: Get Tax Smart Early
[38:39] David: As we wind down, Jason, are there any actionable items you want to leave our listening audience with today?
[38:49] Jason: I would just advise people to get tax smart. We started the conversation with regret. Find the right professionals who can help you throughout your life, get to know them, and get acclimated to tax planning early rather than late. That way you make incremental changes each year that can ultimately have a huge impact on your financial well-being over a long period of time. There are all sorts of tools we can use in the planning process, and we try to simplify things as much as possible. We have hypothetical illustrations and educational videos. When we’re talking to clients, it’s education. We’re never pushy salespeople, and we have no reason to be. We lay out the pros, the cons, the benefits, the risks, and all the information you need to make an informed decision. If you want to proceed, we can facilitate it and make it happen.
[39:56] David: Great information. I really enjoyed our conversation today, Jason. This is the one area I really get excited about, because I know the impact it can have, and this is information that isn’t really out in the general space. You have to look for it, and your firm and our firm are on the front end of trying to make people aware of it, provide the education, and then the leadership if necessary.
[40:24] David: So if you’re listening today, this has been enlightening for you, and you want to get in touch with Jason or me: we don’t typically promote scheduling appointments on our podcast, but if you want to learn more, check out the show notes and our website at thrivefinancialservices.com. If you want to set up a consultation, you can do that right on the website, and we’ll get you connected with Jason. We work in conjunction with Jason on these types of situations, and we’ll get you all the information you need to find out whether these are viable options for you.
[41:02] David: Once again, Jason, I really want to thank you for being on the show. We’re going to invite you back, because I think we could go a little deeper on some of the things out there, and I suspect we’re going to get tons of feedback on this episode. We want to make sure we deliver for the listening audience. So folks, see you on our next episode. Appreciate you listening.
[41:19] Jason: Thank you, David. Thank you, folks. Take care.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between tax preparation and tax planning?
Tax preparation records what already happened and calculates what you owe or the refund you’re due. Tax planning is proactive: during the year, you look for deductions, credits, and deferrals that can lower your tax bill before you file. David and Jason argue that many retirees get preparation but not planning.
What is an accredited investor?
Under SEC rules, an individual generally qualifies as an accredited investor with a net worth over $1 million, not counting a primary residence, or with income over $200,000 (or $300,000 together with a spouse or spousal equivalent) in each of the past two years and the expectation of the same this year. Regulation D private placements like the ones discussed in this episode are generally limited to accredited investors.
When should I start tax planning for retirement?
Earlier is generally better. Starting in your early to mid-60s may give you about 10 years to spread Roth conversions out and pair them with deductions before required minimum distributions begin. Starting later still helps, though conversions may happen more slowly.
Talk to Thrive About Retirement Tax Planning
If you’d like to know whether these strategies could fit your situation, Thrive’s advisors work alongside Jason’s team to review your taxes, income, and retirement goals. Learn how to work with Thrive, take our retirement self-assessment, or join one of our retirement workshops.
Disclosures
Thrive Capital Management LLC is an SEC registered investment advisory firm. SEC registration does not constitute an endorsement of the firm by the SEC, nor does it indicate a particular level of skill or ability. Insurance products and services offered through Thrive Financial Services LLC. Thrive Financial Services and Thrive Capital Management LLC are affiliated companies. For more information, please visit adviserinfo.sec.gov and search for our firm name.
This podcast is for informational purposes only and is not intended as legal, tax, or investment advice or as a recommendation of any particular security or strategy. The investment strategies and themes discussed herein may be unsuitable for investors depending on their specific investment objectives and financial situation. Information obtained from third-party sources is believed to be reliable, though its accuracy is not guaranteed. Opinions expressed in this commentary reflect subjective judgments of the author based on conditions at the time of publication and are subject to change without notice. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
Any references to protection benefits or lifetime income generally refer to fixed insurance products, never securities or investment products. Insurance and annuity product guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. Converting an employer plan account or traditional IRA to a Roth IRA is a taxable event. Increased taxable income from the Roth IRA conversion may have several consequences, including, but not limited to, a need for additional tax withholding or estimated tax payments, the loss of certain tax deductions and credits, and higher taxes on Social Security benefits and higher Medicare premiums. Be sure to consult a qualified tax advisor before making any decisions regarding your IRA. See our full disclosures.