Is Your Retirement Plan Complete? The 5 Critical Areas of Retirement Planning

Is your retirement plan complete, or is it really just an investment plan? Most people nearing retirement are happy with how their savings have grown, but a plan built only around investments leaves out the other areas that decide whether retirement works. In this solo episode of Thrive in Retirement, David Bezar, senior managing partner at Thrive Financial Services, walks through the five critical areas of retirement in Thrive’s ROUTE framework and turns them into a retirement planning checklist you can score yourself on, from 1 to 10. He explains how to measure investment risk, what a year-by-year income plan includes, and how Social Security timing, Medicare, IRMAA surcharges, Roth conversions, and estate documents fit together.

Key Takeaways

  • A complete retirement plan covers five areas, not just investments: Risk, Optimizing income, Unplanned healthcare costs, Taxes, and Estate planning (ROUTE).
  • Know your risk tolerance as a number from 1 to 100, plus the dollar and percentage loss your portfolio would see in a decline like 2008–2009.
  • A year-by-year cash flow and tax plan should show where your income comes from, the tax impact, and when to claim Social Security.
  • Required minimum distributions, pensions, and Social Security together can push income into IRMAA surcharge levels on Medicare Part B and Part D premiums.
  • Score each area from 1 to 10, with no sevens. Two or three scores of 1 to 6 suggest a second opinion may be worthwhile.

What Makes a Complete Retirement Plan?

According to David, an incomplete plan is one built mainly around investments: how they’re performing, what’s being bought and sold, and how long the money will last. A complete plan also addresses income, healthcare, taxes, and your estate, with enough detail that you aren’t relying on estimates. If you already work with an advisor, the questions in this episode can help you check whether your plan covers all five areas. For more on that conversation, see how to re-interview your financial advisor before retirement.

What Is the ROUTE Retirement Planning Framework?

ROUTE is Thrive’s acronym for the five critical areas of retirement. David first introduced it in episode 2 of Thrive in Retirement, the ROUTE framework.

Your Retirement Planning Checklist: The ROUTE Self-Evaluation

Score yourself from 1 to 10 in each area. An 8, 9, or 10 means you’re confident. A 1 through 6 signals concern, and the lower the score, the greater the concern. There are no sevens. Here’s what David says you need in place to score an 8 or higher:

  • Risk: a numeric risk score from 1 to 100, plus the dollar amount and percentage your portfolio would lose in a correction like 2008–2009.
  • Optimizing income: a year-by-year cash flow tax efficiency plan, an understanding of Social Security (timing, election choices, and taxation), and a clear claiming age based on your health, finances, and taxes.
  • Unplanned healthcare: an understanding of Medicare Parts A, B, C, and D and supplemental plans, an understanding of IRMAA, and a strategy, including RMD timing, to keep IRMAA surcharges low.
  • Taxes: knowing how Roth conversions work and how much to convert each year, plus one to three proactive tax strategies that create deductions.
  • Estate planning: an updated will, advance medical directive, durable power of attorney, and possibly a living trust; a plan for where assets go that avoids probate; and, where assets warrant, trust structures reviewed with an estate planning attorney.

Prefer to score yourself online? Take our retirement self-assessment.

Full Episode Transcript

This transcript has been lightly edited for readability.

[0:00] So risk really becomes very paramount in retirement, because we’re really trying to get to the essence of what your comfort level is with risk. And hopefully this will give you some information to either work with your existing advisor and ask them these types of questions, to make sure that you’re getting a plan in place that’s going to work for you.

Why Details Matter in Retirement Planning

[0:30] Hey folks, welcome in to another episode of the Thrive in Retirement podcast. I’m David Bezar, your host, senior managing partner here at Thrive Financial Services. In today’s episode, we’re going to talk about detail. We’re going to go through details. Putting a financial plan in place is not something to take lightly. It’s not about making estimates or just typing in numbers. It’s not only the data and the numbers that are important, but also understanding what should be included in the analysis, so that you’re ultimately putting your plan on a solid foundation that gives you confidence.

[1:17] What we do here at Thrive, and you may be familiar with this unless you’re brand new to the podcast, is work only with people who are either a couple of years away from retirement or currently in retirement. We don’t work with young families. We don’t really help people on their journey to retirement, that accumulation phase. Most of the people we speak with have either done it on their own, which is a smaller percentage, or, for the vast majority, are working with a current financial advisor. And most financial advisors and clients are satisfied. They’ve done a good job. They’ve accumulated the nest egg they need to get to retirement.

Complete vs. Incomplete Retirement Plans

[2:04] But we’re now at that critical point where we have to make sure we’ve got a proper plan in place. Not an incomplete plan, but a complete plan. What do I mean by that? Typically, an incomplete plan is one that’s primarily focused on investments. How are they performing? What am I buying and selling? How long is this money going to last? It’s totally oriented around the investment component of a retiree’s life. The reason it’s incomplete is that it’s missing the four other critical areas of retirement.

[2:40] So to make it simple for people, we’ve come up with an acronym called ROUTE, R-O-U-T-E, where each letter represents one of the five critical areas of retirement. I want to start at the beginning and go into the detail, and hopefully this will give you some information to either work with your existing advisor and ask them these types of questions, to make sure you’re getting a plan in place that’s going to work for you. It’s not arbitrary. It’s not guesstimates. You really want to know as much detail as you possibly can to give yourself the confidence that this is going to work for you.

Risk Management: Understanding Investment Risk

[3:26] So let’s start with the R. The R stands for the risk inside your investment portfolio. When people hear the word risk, a lot of different things go through their minds. You definitely want to ask yourself: how did we determine our family’s risk profile, to help decide what investments we were going to make and at what time?

[3:57] As I’m recording this podcast today, November 5th I think it is, the Dow is down over 1,000 points. The NASDAQ is down over 1,000 points, and the S&P around 300 points. This is kind of a byproduct of what just happened with the elections and everything else. But bring the future to the present. What if this is the beginning of a downturn in the market, and this is when you’re retiring? This is when you’re going to have to start making distributions out of your investment accounts. So risk becomes very paramount in retirement.

[4:39] I’ve spoken to many, many people who have shared with me that they haven’t considered their risk. They haven’t thought about it. They feel like they’re okay with their risk primarily because their investments have done well for a long period of time. It’s amazing, in my experience of 37 years, how quickly someone’s attitude toward risk changes once they’ve seen a decent stretch of a bear market.

Why Risk Categories Aren’t Enough

[5:04] So you have to ask yourself how you determined your risk profile. Usually it’s a questionnaire, maybe five or six questions, and then it categorizes you anywhere from principal protection, conservative, moderate, growth-oriented, aggressive growth, or ultra-aggressive growth. What we’ve learned is that those categories aren’t descriptive or detailed enough. There’s too much of a potential gap between what’s considered aggressive growth versus growth.

Measuring Risk Tolerance

[5:42] These are important. So we use a software planning tool, currently called Nitrogen. It helps a retiree determine, in a very detailed way, what their risk tolerance is. We get that through a questionnaire of about 20 questions, and what’s unique about it is that it asks the same question in a lot of different ways, because we’re really trying to get to the essence of what your comfort level is with risk. The great part about the tool is that it assigns a numeric value. On a scale from 1 to 100, 1 is the most conservative, no risk whatsoever, 100% principal protection, and 100 is the exact opposite, the most speculative it could be. Getting an actual numeric value really gives you a sense of where you are on the risk curve.

Getting a Retirement Planning Second Opinion

[6:50] Now, why is that all important? We do a lot of seminars and webinars, and I always get the question: “Should I come in for a complimentary evaluation? I’m working with a financial advisor. I think I’m doing pretty well.” My answer is always, “I don’t know. I haven’t seen anything you’re doing.” But what we’ve done is construct a small process you can use to self-evaluate, and based on the scores it gives you, it will help you decide whether it makes sense to at least come in and get a second opinion. The reason I bring all this up about risk is that it’s the first of the five critical areas of retirement in this self-evaluation.

The ROUTE Self-Evaluation

[8:02] The self-evaluation is a scale from 1 to 10. A score of 8, 9, or 10 means you’re satisfied. You’re good, you’re confident, everything’s okay, and there’s not really a need to come in and evaluate that area. A score from 1 to 6 means you have some area of concern. The lower the score, the higher the concern. A 1 would mean, “I don’t have any understanding of this. I’m very concerned that I don’t have my head wrapped around this area of retirement.”

You’ll notice I didn’t say anything about a 7. We don’t have any sevens in our scoring, because that’s like sitting on the fence, not having a good feeling or a bad feeling, just sitting in the middle. If you have two or three of the five critical areas where you’re scoring 1 to 6, then it’s a pretty easy decision to come in for that complimentary evaluation.

Three Important Investment Risk Measurements

[9:10] So in risk, the R, to be an 8, 9, or 10, here’s the detail you’d want to have. Number one, you have a risk score as described. Someone has done that assessment, and you have a numeric value from 1 to 100 for your risk tolerance. That’s one criterion. Second, in a market correction, and there are a number of corrections you could use, but the one most prevalent in people’s recent memory is the 2008 through 2009 Great Recession decline, you would know exactly the dollar amount of principal you would lose if you experienced a similar correction.

And you’d know the percentage drop: what percent decline your portfolio would experience if we went through that type of correction again. So those three things: risk score, percentage, and dollar amount. If you have all three, you’d be an 8, 9, or 10. If you don’t have them, or you only have one of the three, you’d be a 1 through 6, which would indicate it may be worthwhile to have the risk area of your retirement plan reviewed, evaluated, and scored. So that’s the R.

Optimizing Retirement Income

[10:54] The O is optimizing income and assets: optimizing your income and optimizing the location of your assets. Again, same scale. 1 through 6 is an area of concern, and 8, 9, or 10 means you’re in good shape. To be an 8, 9, or 10 in optimizing income, you’d need a few things. Number one, a cash flow tax efficiency plan. This is a year-by-year plan showing where your income is distributed from, what the tax impact is going to be, what tax plan you may have in place, when to take Social Security, and what pension strategy to use if you have a pension. All of those components are spelled out in a detailed year-by-year plan. We call ours the Money Map. Other firms have different names for it, but you want to make sure you have a detailed year-by-year plan. That’s one of the criteria.

[12:04] The second part is that you understand all the aspects of Social Security: timing, election choices, taxation on it, the impact, all of that. And third, you know the optimal time to take Social Security based on your personal conditions: health, financial condition, tax consequences, all of that. So the three criteria to be an 8, 9, or 10 are a year-by-year cash flow tax efficiency plan, understanding all the aspects of Social Security, and knowing exactly when to take Social Security so you optimize the benefit that gets paid to you and your family. That’s the O.

Medicare and Unplanned Healthcare Costs

[12:55] The U is unplanned healthcare expenses. For a score of 8, 9, or 10, you would need to understand all the aspects of Medicare. Understand the different components, A, B, C, and D. Understand when it comes in, whether you have to take it, and what you have to take. Understand the addition of a supplemental plan. Basically, all the aspects of Medicare. We find it’s an area most people are not overly educated in. There are a lot of experts out there who can assist you with it, but to be an 8, 9, or 10, you understand all the different aspects of Medicare.

IRMAA and Medicare Surcharges

[13:43] The additional criterion to be scored an 8, 9, or 10 in the unplanned healthcare expense category is that you understand IRMAA surcharges. These are the surcharge penalties where, if you make too much money for your category, you’re assessed an additional premium payment on your Medicare Part B and Medicare Part D. So the additional criterion is understanding all the pieces of IRMAA. And the third criterion is having a strategy in place to keep IRMAA surcharges to a minimum during your retirement, which includes your required minimum distribution timing. A lot of times people don’t plan for that additional income. They’re unaware that now that they’re taking full Social Security, a pension if they have one, and their distributions, it may bump them up into a Medicare IRMAA surcharge level.

So you want a plan to mitigate that, which may include the idea of doing Roth conversions. If you’ve got all of those things in place, you’d be an 8, 9, or 10. If you don’t have those three things in place, you’d fall into the 1 through 6 category based on your concern. The lower the score, the higher the concern. That would give you an indication that you may want to get an evaluation done there.

Tax Planning and Roth Conversions

[15:27] The next category is one where we most often have people marking themselves a 1 through 6 and coming in for the customized complimentary consultation. In taxes, the T, you’d be an 8, 9, or 10 if you understand exactly how Roth conversions work and you know how much you should convert in a given year so that ultimately you’re paying less in taxes. The second is that you have one to three proactive tax planning strategies that will provide a deduction to offset some of your annual income, so that you potentially end up in a lower tax bracket. If you have those things under control, you’d be an 8, 9, or 10. If not, especially with this tax one, you’d be a 1 through 6, which would justify coming in for an evaluation.

Estate Planning

[16:36] And then the last one is estate, the E, for estate planning. I think this is one of the areas where there’s definitely a lack of planning. This isn’t a political statement, but with the recent election, we’ll likely see a change in control, probably toward a sentiment that’s more favorable to increasing taxation overall. So you should have that in the back of your mind and be planning for it, especially when it comes to estate planning. One thing people forget in estate planning is that, with proper planning and investment strategy, the net worth you have today could be a lot more by the time you pass away. So you may not think estate planning applies to you today, but if we bring that future to the present, you may need some estate planning in place.

[17:46] To be an 8, 9, or 10 on the estate planning side, you need to have an updated will, an advance medical directive, a durable power of attorney, and possibly a living trust, depending on your situation. That’s one of the criteria. Second, you know exactly where your money is going after you pass away, so that you’re avoiding probate. And third, if you have enough in assets, you’ve spoken to an estate planning attorney and potentially have the right type of trust structures in place to make sure your loved ones are properly protected from an estate tax perspective. So again, if you have those things in place, you’re an 8, 9, or 10 on the self-evaluation. If you don’t, you’d be a 1 through 6.

Evaluating Your Retirement Plan

[18:43] So you can watch this recording of the podcast, go through ROUTE, R-O-U-T-E, and do the self-evaluation from 1 to 10, no sevens allowed. Use it to help determine whether you want to get all the detail on those five critical areas from your existing financial advisor, or schedule a complimentary consultation with one of our advisors here at Thrive. I hope that helped, and I hope it made sense. Our goal here at Thrive is to be an educational resource for pre-retirees and retirees, so your feedback really helps. You can always call in to schedule that appointment or give us your feedback at 800-516-5861, or reach us through our website at thrivefinancialservices.com. We’ve got a lot of great episodes coming up and a lot of new guests, so stay tuned, and we’ll see you on our next episode. Thanks for listening.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the five critical areas of retirement planning?

In Thrive’s ROUTE framework, the five areas are Risk in your investment portfolio, Optimizing income and assets, Unplanned healthcare expenses, Taxes, and Estate planning. A plan that only covers investments addresses the first area and leaves out the other four, which is why David calls it incomplete.

How do I know if my retirement plan is complete?

Score each ROUTE area from 1 to 10. If you have the specific items David describes for an area, such as a numeric risk score, a year-by-year income plan, or a strategy to manage IRMAA, you’d score an 8, 9, or 10. If two or three areas fall between 1 and 6, your plan likely has gaps worth reviewing with your advisor or through a second opinion.

How much investment risk should I take in retirement?

That depends on your comfort level and your situation, which is why the episode focuses on measuring it precisely. Instead of a broad label like “moderate” or “growth,” David recommends a numeric risk score from 1 to 100 based on a detailed questionnaire. You should also know the dollar amount and percentage your portfolio could lose in a decline like 2008–2009.

How do Roth conversions affect Medicare premiums?

A Roth conversion adds taxable income in the year you convert, which can raise your Medicare Part B and Part D premiums through IRMAA surcharges. Medicare generally sets those surcharges using your income from two years earlier. Over time, though, conversions can reduce future required minimum distributions, which may help keep income below IRMAA thresholds later. That trade-off is why the amount you convert each year matters. Learn more about how Roth conversions may affect retirement taxes.

When should I get a second opinion on my retirement plan?

Consider one if you score 1 to 6 in two or three of the five ROUTE areas, or if you aren’t sure how your current plan handles risk, income, Medicare, taxes, or estate planning. A second opinion can confirm what’s working and point out gaps before you start taking distributions in retirement.

Get a Complimentary Retirement Evaluation

If your self-evaluation turned up areas of concern, a Thrive advisor can review your plan across all five ROUTE areas. Learn how to work with Thrive or take our retirement self-assessment to get started.

Disclosures

Thrive Capital Management LLC is an SEC registered investment advisory firm. SEC registration does not constitute an endorsement of the firm by the SEC, nor does it indicate a particular level of skill or ability. Insurance products and services offered through Thrive Financial Services LLC. Thrive Financial Services and Thrive Capital Management LLC are affiliated companies. For more information, please visit adviserinfo.sec.gov and search for our firm name.

This podcast is for informational purposes only and is not intended as legal, tax, or investment advice or as a recommendation of any particular security or strategy. The investment strategies and themes discussed herein may be unsuitable for investors depending on their specific investment objectives and financial situation. Information obtained from third-party sources is believed to be reliable, though its accuracy is not guaranteed. Opinions expressed in this commentary reflect subjective judgments of the author based on conditions at the time of publication and are subject to change without notice. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Any references to protection benefits or lifetime income generally refer to fixed insurance products, never securities or investment products. Insurance and annuity product guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. Converting an employer plan account or traditional IRA to a Roth IRA is a taxable event. Increased taxable income from the Roth IRA conversion may have several consequences, including, but not limited to, a need for additional tax withholding or estimated tax payments, the loss of certain tax deductions and credits, and higher taxes on Social Security benefits and higher Medicare premiums. Be sure to consult a qualified tax advisor before making any decisions regarding your IRA. See our full disclosures.