Unemployment and Oil Prices Skyrocket

Questions? Let's get connected!

Our mission at Thrive is to take the time to learn your personal financial situation and history so that we can help you develop a personalized retirement strategy. Whether you’re just getting started or are ready to retire, our team is here for you every step of the way!


Weekly Market Update — April 6, 2020


  • U.S. markets struggled with a lot of historically bad news this week and ended the week negative, reversing last week\’s historic gains
  • The smaller–cap Russell 2000 fared the worst by far, dropping over 7% on the week and ending the week with a YTD return of -36.9%
  • The mega-cap DJIA lost 2.7%, followed by the broader, but still large-cap S&P 500\’s return of -2.1% and the tech-laden NASDAQ\’s loss of 1.7%
  • International stocks – as measured by the large-cap, developed–markets MSCI EAFE Index – dropped less than U.S. indices, losing about 1.4%
  • Of the 11 S&P 500 sectors, Utilities and Financials turned in the worst performance, dropping 7.1% and 6.8%, respectively
  • The Health Care (+2.0%) and Consumer Staples (+3.5%) sectors were a couple of bright spots
  • The Energy sector turned in a rare winning week, gaining 5.4% on the heels of the price of oil surging over 30% on the week
  • The Department of Labor reported that weekly initial jobless claims soared to a record 6.6 million, bringing the total jobless claims of the past two weeks to almost 10 million
  • Manufacturing numbers, taken at face–value, appear to be positive, but like the Employment Situation report from the DOL, the data is rear–mirror facing and not indicative of current numbers
  • Volatility, as measured by the CBOE Volatility Index, could be considered another bright spot, as it started the week at 63 and ended the week at 43

Weekly Market Performance

Close Week YTD
DJIA 21,053 -2.7% -26.2%
S&P 500 2,489 -2.1% -23.0%
NASDAQ 7,373 -1.7% -17.8%
Russell 2000 1,052 -7.1% -36.9%
MSCI EAFE 1,487 -1.30% -26.99%
*Bond Index 2,298.95 0.64% 3.32%
10-Year Treasury Yield 0.59% -0.1% -1.3%

*Source: Bonds represented by the Bloomberg Barclays US Aggregate Bond TR USD. This chart is for illustrative purposes only and does not represent the performance of any specific security. Past performance cannot guarantee future results.

Stocks Endure Another Volatile Week

Stock markets around the world were volatile once again this week, but the volatility declined as the week wore on. In a nutshell, there were more bad days compared to good days, and the major U.S. market indices ended the week painted red.

The smaller–cap stocks more than doubled the losses of their larger–cap counterparts, as the Russell 2000 Index gave back more than 7% compared to the declines of about 2% for the DJIA and the S&P 500.


Unemployment numbers weighed heavily on Wall Street until the Department of Labor released official numbers Friday morning. And by all accounts, the 6.6 million jobless numbers were more than most expected, especially since the Employment Situation Report is not real–time data. Economists are suggesting the real unemployment number is closer to 10% versus the 4.4% reported by the DOL, with many suggesting that 10% is far too low as well.

The Health Care and Consumer Staples sectors were two bright spots within the 11 sectors of the S&P 500 this week. But much of the focus was on oil prices, which soared by more than 30% when reports surfaced that Russia and Saudi Arabia might be close to a deal. The rapid rise in the price of oil helped push the Energy sector to a 5.4% gain on the week.

The Middle of the Week was the End of the First Quarter

The first quarter of 2020 ended on Tuesday and investors are glad that it\’s in the rear–view mirror. Remember when your parents said, “if you can’t say anything nice about so and so, don\’t say anything at all?” It was that kind of quarter.

Here is a quick snapshot:

  • The DJIA lost more than 23% for the quarter, its worst since the fourth quarter of 1987
  • It was the worst first quarter for the DJIA in history
  • The S&P 500 lost 20% for the first quarter, its worst since the fourth quarter of 2008
  • It was the worst first quarter for the S&P 500 in history

Massive Spike in Unemployment

Last week, headlines worldwide screamed that the unemployment rate was the highest level in history, as initial jobless claims came in at 3,283,000, an increase of 3,001,000 from the previous week\’s level. And the headlines were not wrong: that week was the highest level of initial claims in history, besting the previous high of 695,000 from October of 1982.


Well, this Friday, that record was shattered as the DOL reported that there were 6.6 million unemployed. But the reality is, the Employment Situation Report is backwards-looking, meaning that it has not fully captured what\’s happening today – much like the recently reported ISM Non-Manufacturing Index. The next few months will better capture the full extent of unemployment, with some suggesting that the unemployment rate will be closer to 10%, not the currently reported 4.4%.

In addition, the DOL reported that average hourly earnings for March were up 0.4% after increasing 0.3% in February. Those hourly earnings numbers are expected to change significantly too.

Manufacturing Data

The Institute for Supply Management reported that economic activity in the non-manufacturing sector grew in March for the 122nd consecutive month as its ISM Non–Manufacturing Index came in at 52.5% versus 57.3% in February. Economists consider the dividing line between expansion and contraction to be at 50.0%.

In other words, the data suggests that this means continued growth in the non–manufacturing sector, but at a slower rate this month compared to the previous month.

Some will suggest, however, that the numbers are not as encouraging as they might appear, as the data has not yet caught up to actual business levels impacted by the coronavirus.

Oil Prices Remain Volatile

Contributing to the recent stock sell-off was the tumbling cost of oil. Remember when the price of Brent Crude, the international standard, plummeted by almost 25% over the weekend of March 7th and 8th alone, which was on top of a more than 10% drop on the previous day? Then on the following Monday, the price of oil was about $34/barrel, its lowest level since 2016. Well, oil ended the quarter just north of $22/barrel.

But then this past Thursday, oil prices spiked a staggering 30%+ after President Trump tweeted that Saudi Arabia and Russia would cut production by 10 to 15 million barrels per day. Within hours of the President\’s tweets, confusion ensued and Russia denied that there was an agreement, with Saudi Arabia seemingly confirming soon thereafter that a deal wasn\’t reached.


Now the worry is that supply is so bountiful that we might run out of room to actually store all of it. And some are suggesting that the price of oil could turn around and head south soon. Consider this: according to Bloomberg News, Wyoming crude grade was recently bid at negative 19 cents a barrel.

Corporate Earnings are Declining

With everyone focused on volatility and market swings, the media has not covered corporate earnings in as much detail as past quarters. But research firm FactSet is reporting that analysts are making huge cuts to corporate earnings estimates.

From FactSet\’s Release dated April 3rd:

“The Q1 bottom–up EPS estimate (which is an aggregation of the median EPS estimates for Q1 for all the companies in the index) declined by 9.1% (to $36.97 from $40.68) from December 31 to March 31.”

For comparison purposes, FactSet further reports:

“In fact, the bottom-up EPS estimate for Q1 witnessed the largest quarterly decline since Q1 2016 (-9.8%) and the eighth largest quarterly decline since FactSet began tracking this data in Q2 2002. However, it should be noted the decrease in Q1 2020 was much smaller than the declines of -34.3% and -31.3% recorded for Q4 2008 and Q1 2009.”



Have questions? Schedule a call!

We can meet with zero obligations on your part. If you can invest one hour today for a no-obligation consultation, we can place you on the path toward owning your tomorrow.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Call Now Button